Firth and Fell

Larder and Lore

What comes out of the Clyde

From creel-caught lobster to the herring fishery that collapsed, the waters around Arran offer a more revealing story than a simple list of catches.

I tend to begin with the old herring story. The Clyde fishery was once one of the largest in Scotland, then collapsed in the twentieth century through overfishing. It is a stark reminder that the contents of a coast are not simply a menu; they are also a record of pressure and change.

What shellfish comes from around Arran?

Langoustines, also called Dublin Bay prawns or Norway lobsters, are caught in the Firth of Clyde. Lobsters and crabs are caught in creels around Arran’s coast. The names are worth keeping straight: a langoustine is not the same thing as a lobster, however close the alternative name Norway lobster makes them sound.

There is a plain pleasure in this list. These are distinct catches from the waters around the island, not one generic idea of seafood. The creel-caught lobster and crab have a particularly clear connection to the coast; the langoustine belongs to the wider firth.

Where do the scallops live?

King scallops live on the sandy and gravel seabed around Arran. They are gathered by divers, as well as by dredgers in some areas. That difference matters: the same shellfish can reach the table by more than one method, and the method belongs in any honest account of the catch.

The story is not only about what can be taken. Lamlash is the protected bay where scallops recovered, a phrase that points to a different kind of relationship between a place and its shellfish. I find that more interesting than treating scallops as a simple measure of abundance.

What about mussels?

Mussels grow on rocks along Arran’s shores. That is a modest fact, but a useful one: the coast’s shellfish are not all drawn from the sandy and gravel seabed where king scallops live. Different species belong to different parts of the shore and seabed.

The contrast is enough. There is no need to turn every shell into a grand claim about the island. Mussels, scallops, crabs, lobsters and langoustines make for a varied account of the waters, even before the story turns to fish.

What happened to the Clyde herring fishery?

It was once one of Scotland’s largest fisheries. It collapsed in the twentieth century through overfishing. Those two facts sit badly together, which is precisely why the history should not be reduced to a nostalgic tale of plenty.

Herring still has a place in the food tradition of the Clyde coast: kippers are made from herring, and smoked fish is a traditional food. That tradition gives the fishery a present-day trace, but it does not undo its collapse. The setting includes the sound to the west.

Is the catch the whole story of Arran food?

No. The sea is the subject here, but it is not the island’s only food story. A contrast is offered by the island's meat from the hills. The distinction is simple, and better for being simple: land and water each have their own produce.

The broader food picture includes more than shellfish and fish.

For this story, though, the most revealing thread remains the Clyde catch. Langoustines, creel-caught lobster and crab, scallops and mussels describe a varied coast; herring adds the harder lesson of a fishery that was once vast and then collapsed. What deserves to endure in that account: the food tradition, or the memory of what was lost?