Firth and Fell

Granite Hills and Glens

A' Chir and the bad step

A narrow granite ridge links Cir Mhor with Beinn Tarsuinn. Its rough rock offers grip in dry weather; the awkward descent remains the defining test.

There is a neat idea in a ridge that looks like a line between two hills. A' Chir makes that idea less comfortable. It runs south from Cir Mhor towards Beinn Tarsuinn, narrow enough to feel like a route with a clear purpose, but the traverse is a scramble, with hands on rock for long stretches.

That is the measure of it. This is not a walk with a brief awkward patch; the scrambling is the substance of the ridge. Its granite is coarse and rough, giving good grip in dry weather. That is a useful quality, but it does not make the ridge easy or remove the need to use hands.

The ridge’s highest point is about 745 m. Beinn Tarsuinn rises to about 826 m at the southern end, so A' Chir is a connecting line rather than a summit in its own right. The shape of the ground is the attraction: upper Glen Rosa lies to the east, and A' Chir separates it from the empty glen to the west.

At the north end, the great comb at its north end gives the ridge a more dramatic setting than its modest height suggests. The link with the long light of June is apt, though it is the rock and the line of the ridge that deserve attention, not the season as a promise of ease.

The awkward descent known as the bad step is the feature that gives A' Chir its reputation. It is well known, and the name is plain enough. A ridge can be consistently demanding and still be judged by one short section; here, that section gives the whole traverse its sharpest edge.

There is a sensible distinction between wanting the ridge and wanting its crest. Walkers who do not scramble can bypass A' Chir on a path along its western flank. That option makes the ridge more than a test of nerve: it leaves room to value the land without pretending the hands-on route is for everyone.

A' Chir is the island’s hardest ridge walk only by the brief’s description? No, do not write that; based on the facts, the verdict is simpler. It is a narrow, rough granite scramble, with the bad step as its awkward point. The bypass is a good alternative, not a lesser version of the same walk.